Archive for the Amy Barrett’s Supreme Court Hearing Category

A WITCH WITH A WINSOME SMILE?

Posted in 1968 Columbia Student Strike, Amy Barrett's Supreme Court Hearing with tags , , on October 16, 2020 by playthell

A Smiling Assassin?

Notes on A Dangerous, Duplicitous, Dame

Despite her innocent smile and pious religious posture, Judge Amy Coney Barrett demonstrated consummate skill employing legal jargon to avoid fundamental questions regarding constitutional restrictions on presidential power. Most shocking was her refusal to give a straight answer to the simple question: “Can the President unilaterally change the date of the presidential election”

Although it is clearly stated in the Constitution that Congress alone is empowered to set the date, and it has been clearly established on a specific date, every four years, Judge Barrett was unsure! She said she could not answer the question without having the case come before her and consulting with her clerks and colleagues. DUH? I can answer that question, or any literate person, by just reading the Constitution.

Yet this learned legal scholar and sitting Federal Judge must consult others in order to arrive at the conclusion that the President has no power to postpone an election. Interestingly, Bill Barr – that lying fat face fraud who has disgraced the Department of Justice doing Devious Donnie’s dirty deeds – was equally vague when questioned on this issue by a congressional committee.

Barr said he had never given the matter any thought and could not answer the question without studying the matter. The fact that Barr and Amy were also wishy washy on the question of the peaceful transfer of presidential following an election, a procedure that is also clearly spelled out in the Constitution is real cause for worry.

While we have been fairly inundated with evidence of Judge Barret’s accomplishment’s as a law professor at Notre Dame, the iconic Jesuit university where she was trained that is best known for its football team, and the fact that she has written 100 legal opinions during her tenure on the federal bench, she was MUM on her views on a variety of issues that are fundamental to the life chances of Americans, and the health of our constitutional democracy such as whether the President can pardon himself for past and future crimes. She was as secretive as a dope dealer!

Although Trump has stated on numerous occasions what he expects from the Judges he appoints, and it has been reported with bold headlines in newspapers and with much fanfare on television, Amy says she never heard any of it! Hence it is fair to say that is we take the Judge at her word, and she is under oath, she is a space cadet who is oblivious to current events. Otherwise, she has lied to the Senate under after swearing to tell the truth!  In which case she has committed a felony!

The history of the Supreme Court affords numerous examples of Justices who ruled against the positions of the Presidents who appointed them, but this woman was vetted by the Federalist Society. And Senator Whitehouse did a great job of exposing the hornet’s nest of invisible donors and far right organizations who investigate and select candidates to the Supreme Court with great certainty of where they stand on critical issues. Senator Whitehouse also showed that the Judges they select have an amazing record of voting the way they are expected to once installed on the High Court. He went on to show how Amy Coney Barrett is a product of this selection process.  And her explanation to Senator Cory Booker’s question as to  why she voted against an Afro-American plaintiff who claimed he was a victim of a “hostile work environment,” although his work supervisor called him “a nigger” was the essence of lawyerly double talk.

Hence, I don’t trust her. I think she is a witch with a winsome smile, a devil with an angel face.  She will be confirmed. The Republican leaders of the Senate such as majority leader Mad Mitch McConnell, and Judiciary Committee Chairman Lying Lindsay Graham has already declared victory. They are rushing her through the confirmation despite the pious palaver they spouted about not confirming Supreme Court Justices in an election year!

This is the reason these charlatans gave when they rejected outright President Obama’s Supreme Court nominee Judge Merritt Garland, and his black female appointee Mira Selby to the Federal bench; a seat now held by Amy Barrett, whom Trump later appointed! Amy is their girl and I have little doubt that she will do their bidding, for the next 30 years or more.

This is brazen Court packing, and the Democrats should expand the number of justices on the Supreme Court to nullify their treachery! That’s why all who oppose Dirty Donald and his far- right backers must turn out and vote to send these rascals home!

***************

Playthell Benjamin
Harlem, New York
October 16, 2020

Witness Senator Booker Interrogate Judge Barrett

On Republican Hypocrisy

Posted in Amy Barrett's Supreme Court Hearing with tags , , , on October 15, 2020 by playthell

Devil or Angel?

 The Travesty of Amy Barrett’s Supreme Court Nomination

The confirmation hearings for Justice Amy Barrett is an act of treachery, conceived in malice and conducted with shameless duplicity. For the people now pushing this nomination are the very same people who blocked the nominee of President Barack Obama, Judge Merritt Garland, on the grounds that no nominee should be confirmed to the Supreme Court during an election year, although the nomination was made months before the election. They said that decision, who shall be elevated to the High Court, ought to be left up to the American people in the President they elect.

Now, these radical right-wing Republicans are frantically pushing Barrett’s confirmation after voting for the next president has actually begun. And when reminded of their pious pronouncements about the right of the people to decide this critical question regarding the composition of the Court, they play past the question and continue undaunted in their duplicitous actions.

Unable to present a credible defense of their transparent treachery, the Repubs inundated the public with silly sophistry that is an insult to any thinking American. Anyone who is not down with this dirty deal, or handicapped by the epidemic of ignorance sweeping the nation – a plague more dangerous than the Corona Virus – cannot fail to feel offended by these lying, amoral, shameless, charlatans that insists on pushing this nomination through.  For intelligent young people, from Jr. High-school on, the Republican duplicity provides ample reason to grow cynical about politics; to denounce it, as I have heard some young Americans do, as a hopelessly corrupt process that no self-respecting moral person should get involved in.

Senator Hirono Grills the Judge

Pressing Her Questions with Dogged Persistence

The Democrats in the Senate were magnificent in their unmasking of the Republican masquerade. They are speaking to the real issues that matter to the health and welfare of the American people. They have exposed the retrograde political objectives that Republicans have failed to achieve through politics, and now seek to achieve through a right-wing Supreme Court. And they make it clear that this is the true reason for this confirmation hearing.

Republicans on the judiciary Committee, and their colleagues throughout the Senate, are disgracing themselves and alienating the nation’s youth from their government. But they don’t give a shit, so long as their mission to pack the Federal Judiciary with right-wing judges who will not only arrest the progress women, non-white minorities, labor unions, gay people, et al – “the protected classes” – have made over the last half century. They brazenly select Judges they believe will overturn abortion rights, make it harder for poor and non-white people to vote, and take away health care from 20 million Americans!

WATCH THESE HEARINGS! If you can’t watch in real time watch it later on You Tube. Among other things, the Republican blather will vividly demonstrate what the Princeton philosopher Harry G. Franks so brilliantly described in his book: .”BULLSHIT!”  I will have A LOT more to say about what it will mean for the life chances of black folks, and the priorities of progressive forces in our country. I will offer my speculations on what it will mean for us if Judge Barrett becomes Justice Barrett.

I am unimpressed by all the hoopla about Amy’s academic performance. It is irrelevant when it comes to what she believes about the role and rule of law. Judge Barrett has said that the late Justice Antonin Scalia, a right-wing crank, was the greatest influence on her judicial philosophy. Alas, this fuzzy headed racist thought legal protections against racial discrimination in voting was a misguided “racial entitlement – a belief that is at the root of the massive efforts at suppression of the black vote in the coming election.  At first glance she strikes me as a pious, politically backward, religious fanatic with the instincts of a brood mare. Not someone who has the judicial perspectives that will incline them to vote in the affirmative on the issues progressives care about – this writer first among them.

***************

Playthell G. Benjamin
Harlem, New York
October 15, 2020

Witness Senator Hirono in Action